IoT adoption is accelerating faster than society’s readiness for its full consequences, according to Auto-ID specialist Mohammad Amer Shallah. Historical examples, including air traffic radar, airplane blackboxes, road traffic sensors, fire alarm systems, pollution sensors, and the Chernobyl disaster, show that instantaneous data collection alone does not prevent accidents or drive meaningful action.
What Do Air Traffic Radars Teach About IoT?
Air traffic radar systems show that accurate, real-time data does not guarantee safe outcomes when human performance is weak. Controllers use radar coordinates to guide pilots through sky corridors and prevent collisions, yet airplane crashes have occurred because of human operator error even when the underlying data is precise and instantaneous.
Lesson: Weak human performance can degrade the system even if it is well fed with accurate instantaneous data.
Why Are Airplane Blackboxes an IoT Model?
Airplane blackboxes represent what Mohammad Amer Shallah calls the greatest useful example of the IoT role. Thorough investigations using blackbox data have produced safer aircraft designs and fewer accidents, making air travel one of the safest modes of transport. The key lesson is that data loss renders all collection useless, making parallel backup mechanisms essential.
Lesson: Data loss renders all ofits collection useless. Parallel backup collection incritical applications should be considered such assending info online.
Do Road Traffic Sensors Solve Congestion?
Lesson: Data can tell about thedifficult problems, however, there is inability to make parallel roads wider frequently or provide alternative routes or tunnels.
Why Do Fire Alarms Fail to Stop Fires?
Lesson: Fire fighting is always slower than the spread of fire even if the alarm data is instantaneous.
What Do Pollution Sensors Reveal About Data Use?
Pollution sensors have tracked air, water, sand, and frozen-sea contamination for decades, generating precise measurements and negative-trend data. Annual climate summits raise alarms based on this data, yet no full tangible actions have followed. Data has no value if decision-makers do not act on what it reveals.
Lesson: What is the use of data if there is no serious decision making on what affects all humans and creatures on our planet?
What Does Chernobyl Show About Sensor Limits?
The Chernobyl nuclear disaster occurred at a facility over-equipped with sensors and control panels designed to maintain plant safety. The catastrophe happened despite all monitoring systems and personnel. The lesson from Chernobyl is that precautionary procedures must activate at lower thresholds of critical sensor values, before readings reach accident or catastrophic levels.
Lesson: Precautionary procedures must be taken at a lower thresholds of critical values.
Considering past cases, instantaneous data collection and IoT do not necessarily prevent the disasters to happen. They can give early warnings to take the necessary precautionary measures ahead of reaching an accident or catastrophic levels. Additionally, they provide data for analysis for future assessments and improvements. I consider that the civil aircraft blackbox is the greatest USEFUL example of the role of IoT. The thorough and serious investigations into all air accidents using the blackbox data have lead to better safer designs and less accidents, causing air traveling to be among the safest travel means. Additionally there are trends to come up with more advanced blackboxes.
IoT is a growing trend and it will generate useful big data. I conclude from these lessons some recommendations:
- There should be studies and analysis on all aspects of the collected (really useful) data of any system and the relevant emergency scenarios to face with the extensive proper human training. Data must be enhanced with artificial intelligence.
- Legal rules must be placed determining the responsibility of human operators during specific problems and determining how long an operator is accountable if the analysed data revealed something wrong in an ancient period.
- In theory, world leaders, cabinet members, and parliament members should be all accountable for not taking the right decisions and regulations to stop any environmental damage or deterioration.
- Data logging devices should be made very robust (like aircraft blackboxes) with a parallel backup mechanism in a different place, better being online connected to some other location.
- Determining the connectivity limitations and accessibility rights of collected data as well as the period of storage of such data. Whenever applicable, it is good to publish data on cloud for public access and benefit. Thanks to CERN (hadron collider) this year releasing publicly 300TB of experimental data.
- Each accident must drive to reevaluate the current IoT system and what modifications and additions are required for a safer behavior and better and faster data collection.
In conclusion, there is an acceleration to IoT adoption ahead of being prepared for the full consequences. It is more or less like inventing the first generation of cars without yet having the proper roads, rules, policemen, traffic lights and traffic signs. Many problems, conflicts and dispute will arise legally and costs will be incurred, all for the sake of network instantaneous data.
The article was written by Mohammad Amer Shallah, Auto-ID Support, www.ai-support.com. Amer has been implementing automatic identification, data capture technologies, and mobility for 20 years in domains of business, government and security. The accumulated experience and continuous follow up on latest emerging technologies help him to contribute writings about current trends and highlight challenges. The original articles can be accessed here.
Terms of Use and Copyrights: https://goo.gl/Rl5XoS. Images in the document are “Labeled for reuse” from web search.